Chapter 5 - The Last to Arrive

At 7:09 PM, Nathan’s voice drifted casually into the foyer.
“Sorry I’m late, everyone,” he called out, his tone light, breezy, and entirely unburdened by guilt. “Traffic on the Merritt was a complete parking lot near Exit 33. I swear, if the state doesn't widen that stretch by next year, we’re all going to be commuting by helicopter.”
He stepped into the hallway, shrugging off his charcoal-gray tailored jacket and loosening his silk tie with practiced nonchalance. He smiled toward the living room, his eyes scanning the group of family members standing around with their wine glasses, before his gaze locked onto Elise.
And then, his eyes dropped.
They didn't drift; they plunged straight down to her left hand.
The smile froze on Nathan’s face, dying a sudden, violent death in the space of a heartbeat. His hazel eyes widened, darting from Elise’s bare ring finger back up to her face, searching for tears, for trembling lips, for the familiar, predictable panic of a woman about to break.
Instead, he found a wall of absolute, terrifying ice.
Nathan swallowed hard, his throat working visibly against the sudden dryness. He forced his eyes away from her hand and allowed them to drift past the group toward the center of the room.
That was when he saw it.
The massive, six-foot-tall, linen-covered frame standing directly beneath the crystal chandelier, casting a long, rectangular shadow across the hardwood floor.
Nathan stopped dead in his tracks. The color drained from his face so fast it looked as though someone had pulled a plug in his veins, leaving behind a sickly, grayish pallor that contrasted sharply against his expensive tan.
“What’s... what’s that?” Nathan asked, his voice dropping to a harsh, strained whisper that barely carried over the low hum of the refrigerator in the kitchen.
No one answered. The entire room went dead silent. Even Owen put down his phone, sensing the sudden, violent atmospheric shift in the room.
Elise didn't blink. She turned her head slowly, looking at her husband with an expression so devoid of emotion that it made Nathan physically recoil. Then, she took two measured steps toward the frame, placed her right hand flat against the heavy white linen sheet, and looked straight into his eyes.
“Come closer, Nathan,” Elise said, her voice cutting through the silence like a scalpel. “You wouldn't want to miss the details. After all, you helped design the background.”
Nathan took a half-step backward, his shoulder hitting the mahogany console table in the hallway. “Elise,” he whispered, the name slipping out of him like a plea for mercy. “Elise, whatever you think—whatever you've gotten into your head—let’s not do this here. Let’s go into the study. Just you and me. We can talk about this like adults.”
“Talk?” Elise’s lips curved into a thin, merciless smile. “We’ve spent six years talking, Nathan. You explained every late night at the office. You explained the extra wine glass. You explained why your stepmother’s perfume lingered in the upstairs hallway long after she left Sunday dinner. You were always so good at explaining things.”
Across the room, Harrison set his whiskey glass down on the side table with a sharp clink that made several family members flinch.
“Nathan,” Harrison barked, his voice dropping into that commanding, boardroom register that had intimidated competitors for decades. “What is going on here? What is your wife talking about? What is under that sheet?”
Celeste hadn't moved. She stood by the fireplace, her face completely drained of color, her long crimson nails clenched so tightly around the stem of her wine glass that Elise half-expected the crystal to shatter in her hand. The smug, triumphant confidence she had worn when she walked through the front door had been replaced by a feral, cornered panic.
“Dad,” Nathan stammered, his eyes darting wildly between his father, Celeste, and Elise. “It’s... it’s nothing. Elise is just having an episode. She’s been under a lot of stress at the museum lately with the autumn exhibition, and she’s imagining things—misinterpreting harmless family closeness—”
“Harmless family closeness?” Elise interrupted. Her voice wasn't loud, but it filled every cubic inch of the room, vibrating with a lethal, controlled fury. “Is that what you call sleeping in my bed, under my wedding portrait, while your stepmother rests her crimson-painted hand on your chest?”
The room erupted.
Meredith gasped, clapping a hand over her mouth. Daniel’s professional smile vanished, replaced by a look of stunned disbelief. Lauren dropped her handbag onto the floor with a loud thud, her eyes darting between Nathan and Celeste like a spectator at a tennis match gone horribly wrong.
“What?” Harrison roared, his face turning a dark, mottled purple as he took two aggressive steps toward his son. “Nathan, what in God's green earth is she talking about?”
“Dad, listen to me—” Nathan lunged forward, his hands outstretched in a desperate gesture of pacification. “It’s a hoax. It’s a deepfake, or a malicious photoshop job sent by some disgruntled person trying to extort our firm—Elise is just playing along with a sick prank—”
“A prank?” Elise’s voice cut him off like a whip-crack.
May you like
She gripped the top edge of the linen sheet in both hands.
“Let’s see how much of a prank it is.”