Chapter 2 - The Ghost of Christmas Past (and Present)
At exactly 9:12 p.m., the silence of my kitchen was shattered by the shrill, persistent ringing of my cell phone.
I was sitting in the exact same spot where I had left off three hours earlier, a cup of lukewarm chamomile tea growing cold beside my elbow. I hadn’t touched the pot roast. I hadn’t touched the pie. The thought of eating felt like chewing on dry ashes.
I glanced down at the screen. The display lit up the dark room with a bright, glaring white light, flashing a terrifying statistic: **Nineteen missed calls.**
Every single one of them was from Ethan.
My thumb hovered over the screen. Part of me wanted to let it ring into voicemail, to let him stew in whatever disaster his wife had cooked up for themselves. But a mother’s instinct—that stubborn, unshakable anchor—pulled my finger across the glass. I pressed accept and brought the phone to my ear.
“Mom?”
Ethan’s voice wasn’t just cracking now; it was practically disintegrating. He sounded like a man standing on the edge of a crumbling cliff, gasping for air.
“I’m here, Ethan,” I said, my voice eerily calm compared to his frantic panic.
“Mom, please… please tell me you still have the food. Please tell me you didn’t throw it out.”
I looked across the kitchen table at the three covered aluminum pans, still sitting undisturbed under the dim overhead light.
“What happened, Ethan?” I asked, leaning back in my wooden chair. “Weren’t you having a wonderful dinner with your corporate sponsors, your wealthy investors, and Brooke’s pristine white theme?”
“Mom, don’t,” he choked out, a ragged sob catching in his throat. “Just… please. The caterer. The high-end catering company Brooke hired months ago—the ones charging four hundred dollars a head—they never showed up.”
I blinked. “They never showed up?”
“No!” Ethan cried, his voice rising in pitch, betraying a man at the absolute end of his tether. “Brooke has been on the phone with their emergency dispatch for three hours, but it goes straight to voicemail. They’ve completely ghosted us. And Mom… there are nineteen people sitting in our house right now. Nineteen high-powered executives, my firm’s managing partner, Brooke’s parents, and some big-shot regional director from the corporate office. And nobody—*nobody*—has eaten a single bite since breakfast.”
A strange, dark satisfaction rippled through my chest, though I swallowed it down quickly. Karma is a patient creature, but when she strikes, she doesn’t miss a beat.
“That’s terrible, honey,” I said, letting a touch of heavy irony color my tone. “Really. But I’m sure a group of sophisticated people like that can survive a few hours without food. After all, caviar and minimalism are very filling, aren’t they?”
“Mom, stop!” Ethan begged, the sound of movement heavy in the background of the call—shuffling feet, the distant, muffled murmur of panicked voices, and the sharp, unmistakable sound of crystal glass tapping against a fork. “Brooke is crying in the powder room. Her mother is threatening to call the police on the catering company. And my boss… my boss just asked me if we were running a rehabilitation clinic instead of a Christmas dinner party because everyone’s stomach is growling so loudly.”
I let out a slow, measured breath. “Well, Ethan, you made your bed—or rather, your wife made your theme. What do you expect me to do about it?”
“Brooke’s the one who told me to call you,” he admitted, his voice dropping to a miserable, humiliated whisper. “She said… she said she’s sorry. She said she’ll apologize to your face. She said whatever you want, just bring the food back. Name your price, Mom. Whatever you want.”
I stared at the foil-covered pot roast. I thought about the way Brooke had looked at me six hours ago, treating me like an embarrassing piece of trash left on the front porch. An apology squeezed out of desperation wasn't an apology at all; it was just a business transaction.
“No,” I said firmly.
“No?” Ethan shrieked. “Mom, what do you mean *no*? Nineteen people are starving! My entire career is riding on this dinner party! If this fails, I’m done at the firm!”
“You should have thought about that before you stood by the staircase and watched your wife treat your mother like an unwanted solicitor, Ethan,” I said, my voice hardening like cold steel. “I cooked that food with love, and it was rejected because it didn’t match a color scheme. I’m not bringing it back to a house where I’m treated like an insult.”
There was a long, agonizing pause on the other end of the line. The heavy breathing of my son was the only sound in the receiver.
Then, Ethan spoke again, and his voice had changed. The panic was gone, replaced by a cold, trembling terror that chilled me straight to the bone.
“Mom… there’s something else,” Ethan whispered, his words barely audible above the wind whistling outside my house.
“What else could possibly be wrong?” I asked, frowning.
“I’m not calling from inside the house,” Ethan said. “I’m outside. I stepped out onto the front porch to make this call without Brooke hearing me.”
“So?”
“So… while I was standing out here, a car pulled up into the driveway. A black sedan. A man got out.” Ethan’s breath hitched. “He walked right up the steps past me. He didn’t look at me, he didn’t say a word. He walked straight to the front door, knocked twice, and when Brooke opened it, he didn’t talk about the catering. He asked for you by name, Mom.”
My grip on the phone tightened until my knuckles turned white. “Asked for me? Who?”
“I don’t know,” Ethan whispered, and I could hear the sheer dread vibrating in his chest. “I asked him who he was. He didn’t answer. He just reached into his coat pocket, pulled something out, and handed it to Brooke. And Mom… I caught a glimpse of it under the porch light. He’s holding Dad’s recipe card. The exact one you baked the pecan pie with this morning.”
The phone almost slipped from my sweaty palm.
“What did you say?” I demanded, standing up so fast my kitchen chair scraped loudly against the linoleum floor. “Walter’s recipe card? That’s impossible! It’s sitting right here on my kitchen counter!”
I whipped my head around, my eyes darting to the center of the table.
The aluminum pan containing the pecan pie was still there. But the heavy foil had been peeled back. And resting right beside the pie, stark and unmistakable, was a grease-stained, yellowed index card with Walter’s familiar, loopy handwriting scrawled across it in black ink: *Pecan Pie - Walt’s Secret Crust.*
Except… that wasn't my copy. That card had vanished five years ago, on the day of Walter’s funeral, locked away in a safe deposit box at the bank that I hadn't opened in years.
May you like
“Mom?” Ethan’s voice crackled through the phone. “Mom, are you still there? The man… he’s standing inside the hallway right now with Brooke and her parents. And he’s pointing right at the kitchen door. He wants everyone to see what’s written on the back of that card.”
***
