Chapter 2 - The Evidence in the Safe
By the third week, the burns on my ribs had begun to itch—a maddening, crawling sensation that the nurses warned me was a sign of healing. Healing hurt worse than the initial shock. Every time the skin stretched, it felt like tiny invisible knives were slicing open the new, pink tissue forming beneath the dressings.
Dr. Harrison, a sharp-eyed plastic surgeon with salt-and-pepper hair and a no-nonsense bedside manner, stood at the foot of my bed, reviewing my chart.
"You're healing faster than anticipated, Grace," he said, not looking up from his tablet. "Your physical therapy starts tomorrow. It's going to be brutal. We need to break down the scar tissue before it contracts and permanently limits mobility in your shoulder and right arm."
"I'm ready," I said. My voice was stronger now, though it still rasped like dry paper. The breathing tube trauma had mostly faded.
"Good. Because you're going to need your strength." He tapped the screen and looked up, his expression softening slightly. "There's a detective downstairs. Detective Miller, Boston PD. He’s been asking when you’d be coherent enough for a formal statement regarding the fire at the Sterling brownstone."
My heart gave a sharp, painful thump against my ribs. "A statement?"
"The fire department’s preliminary report listed the cause as undetermined, but arson investigators found some irregularities in the study. Specifically around the antique humidor near the desk. The detective wants to know if anyone was smoking in the house that night."
I stared at the white lilies—which I had made the nurse throw out on the second day—and thought about Caleb.
Caleb didn't smoke cigarettes. Not publicly. But when he was stressed, locked in his private study with his financial ledgers and his offshore accounts, he smoked imported cigars that he kept locked in a humidor. On the night of the fire, he had been drinking heavily, panicking over an SEC audit that was closing in on his firm's real estate holdings. He had dropped a lit cigar onto the Persian rug while stumbling toward the hallway.
When I woke up coughing from the smoke, the study was already an inferno, and Caleb was huddled under the dining table, screaming for help while the flames ate the walls.
"Send him in," I said quietly.
Detective Marcus Miller looked like a man who hadn't slept since 2010. He wore a rumpled tweed jacket, carried a battered leather notepad, and had dark, intelligent eyes that missed nothing. He pulled a chair up beside my bed, sitting down with a faint groan of tired joints.
"Ms. Hayes," he said, flipping open his notepad. "I appreciate you taking the time. I know you've been through hell—literally."
"It's fine, Detective," I replied. "Ask your questions."
"Let's talk about the night of January 14th," Miller said, his pen poised over the paper. "Mr. Sterling’s publicist and legal team have already filed a formal affidavit stating you were an off-hours independent contractor who happened to be on site, and that you accidentally caused the electrical fault while doing unauthorized maintenance."
A cold rage flared in my chest. They weren't just abandoning me; they were framing me for arson and trespassing to protect Caleb's insurance payout and public image.
"Unauthorized maintenance?" I let out a dry, humorless sound. "I lived there, Detective. For six months. My clothes are in the master closet. My art supplies are in the sunroom. My name isn't on the deed, but I have bills, mail, and bank statements sent to that address."
Miller raised an eyebrow, jotting down notes. "Is that so? Because Mr. Sterling’s legal team presented a very different picture. They provided a signed contract—dated six months ago—labeling you as a live-in administrative consultant."
"A non-disclosure agreement disguised as an employment contract," I corrected him. "And they forgot one very important detail."
Miller stopped writing. He looked up, his sharp eyes locking onto mine. "What's that?"
"Caleb is meticulous about his privacy, but he's also arrogant," I said, my voice steady despite the pain in my chest. "He keeps a floor safe behind the mahogany bookshelf in his study. In that safe, there isn't just cash and offshore paperwork. There's a backup hard drive containing every security camera recording inside the brownstone—including the audio and video from the night of the fire."
Miller’s pen hovered. "A hard drive? The fire department report said the study was completely gutted. Everything inside should have been incinerated."
"The study burned," I agreed, a grim smile touching the corners of my mouth. "But the safe is fireproof, rated for 2,000 degrees for four hours. It's anchored to the concrete foundation beneath the floorboards. The fire couldn't touch it."
The detective stared at me for a long moment, processing the strategic weight of what I had just handed him.
"If that drive exists," Miller said slowly, "and if it contains what you say it does, it changes everything. Not just regarding the fire, but regarding insurance fraud, perjury, and potentially corporate embezzlement."
May you like
"It does," I said. "And I know the combination."
Miller closed his notepad with a decisive snap. He slid it into his coat pocket and stood up. "Rest up, Ms. Hayes. You're going to need your strength. Tomorrow, I'm getting a search warrant for the brownstone. And I suspect Mr. Sterling’s lawyers are going to have a very bad week."
